Shelter Island New York

Takeout Restaurants

Takeout Restaurants in Shelter Island

 

• Mama Lisa Italian Seafood Pizza and Restaurant - Mastic

  1495 Montauk Highway, Mastic, 11950

  
• Salsa Salsa - Port Jefferson

  142 Main Street, Port Jefferson, 11777

  
• Bianca Luna Italian Restaurant - Medford

  1600 New York 112, Medford, 11763

  
• Cavaniola's Gourmet Kitchen - Sag Harbor

  89C Division Street, Sag Harbor, 11963

  
• Carrabba's Italian Grill - Smithtown

  Smithtown, 11787

  
• Cull House Restaurant - Sayville

  75 Terry Street, Sayville, 11782

  
• Golden Pear Cafe Sag Harbor - Sag Harbor

  111 Main Street, Sag Harbor, 11963

  
• Claudio's Restaurant - Greenport

  111 Main Street, Greenport, 11944

  
• Salamander's General Store - Greenport

  414 1st Street, Greenport, 11944

  
• Dragon Garden Chinese Takeout Restaurant - Southampton

  369 North Sea Road, Southampton, 11968

  
• Braun Seafood 2 Go - Cutchogue

  30840 Main Road, Cutchogue, 11935

  
• Love Lane Kitchen - Mattituck

  240 Love Lane, Mattituck, 11952

  

 

Dessert Shops

Dessert Shops in Shelter Island

 

• DAIRY QUEEN STORE - Old Saybrook

  1370 Boston Post Road, Old Saybrook, 06475

  
• Magic Fountain - Mattituck

  9825 Main Road, Mattituck, 11952

  
• Carvel - Hampton Bays

  73 East Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, 11946

  
• Scoop Dujour - East Hampton

  35 Newtown Lane, East Hampton, 11937

  
• Ice Cream Club - Sag Harbor

  7 Main Street, Sag Harbor, 11963

  
• Carvel Ice Cream & Bakery - Bridgehampton

  2033 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton, 11932

  
• Tuck Shop - Shelter Island

  75 North Menantic Road, Shelter Island, 11964

  
• Sandpiper - Greenport

  142 Main Street, Greenport, 11944

  
• Big Olass - Sag Harbor

  Long Wharf Street, Sag Harbor, 11963

  
• Scoops - Cutchogue

  28080 Main Road, Cutchogue, 11935

  
• Nina's Ice Cream Parlor - Orient

  1010 Village Lane, Orient, 11957

  

 

Butcher Shops

Butcher Shops in Shelter Island

 

• Carlo and Son Quality Meats - East Lyme

  299 Flanders Road, East Lyme, 06333

  
• Herbs Market - Montauk

  778 Montauk Highway, Montauk, 11954

  
• Cliff's Quality Meats - Essex

  88 Plains Road, Essex, 06426

  
• Bennies Farm Market - Centerbrook

  5 Main Street, Centerbrook, 06409

  
• Wayside Market - Southold

  55575 Route 25, Southold, 11971

  
• My Butcher - Wading River

  6278 Route 25A 3, Wading River, 11792

  
• Village Prime Meat Shoppe - East Quogue

  495 Montauk Highway, East Quogue, 11942

  
• Hampton Prime Meats - Southampton

  235 North Sea Road, Southampton, 11968

  
• Catena's Inc Food Market - Southampton

  143 Main Street, Southampton, 11968

  
• Fedi's Market - Shelter Island

  43 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, 11964

  

 

Bagel Shops

Bagel Shops in Shelter Island

 

• Goldbergs Famous - East Hampton

  100 Pantigo Place, East Hampton, 11937

  
• Twice Upon A Bagel - Wainscott

  358 Montauk Highway, Wainscott, 11975

  
• Neils Donuts - Wallingford

  83 North Turnpike Road, Wallingford, 06492

  
• Bagel Buoy Market - Sag Harbor

  3 Bay Street, Sag Harbor, 11963

  
• Bagels Your Way - Southold

  46519 County Road 48, Southold, 11971

  
• Strathmore Bagel Cafe - Riverhead

  1550 County Road 58, Riverhead, 11901

  
• North Fork Bagel Cafe - Mattituck

  10095 Main Road, Mattituck, 11952

  
• Hampton Bays Bagel - Hampton Bays

  252 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, 11946

  
• Four Oaks Gourmet Deli - Southampton

  42 Jagger Lane, Southampton, 11968

  
• Goldberg's Famous Bagels - Southampton

  801 County Road 39, Southampton, 11968

  

 

Cheese Shops

Cheese Shops in Shelter Island

 

• Foxglove and Madison Cheese Etc - Madison

  724 Boston Post Rd, Madison, 06443

  
• Village Cheese Shop North - Mattituck

  105 Love Lane, Mattituck, 11952

  
• Cavaniola's Gourmet Cheese Shop - Sag Harbor

  89 Division Street, Sag Harbor, 11963

  
• Cato Corner Farm - Colchester

  178 Cato Corner Road, Colchester, 06415

  
• Brie and Bleu Cheese Store - New London

  70 State Street, New London, 06320

  
• Lucy's Whey - East Hampton

  80 North Main Street, East Hampton, 11937

  
• Caseus - New Haven

  93 Whitney Avenue, New Haven, 06510

  
• Star Fish Market - Guilford

  650 Village Walk, Guilford, 06437

  
• Village Gourmet Cheese Shoppe - Southampton

  11 Main Street, Southampton, 11968

  

 

Juice Shops

Juice Shops in Shelter Island

 

• Orange Julius (850 Hartford Turnpike) - Waterford

  850 Hartford Turnpike, Waterford, 06385

  
• Moose Smoothies - Southampton

  395 County Road 39A, Gym, Southampton, 11968

  
• Fruit Occasions by Fruitful Treats - Hamden

  1729 Dixwell Avenue, Hamden, 06514

  
• Pure Health Lounge - New Haven

  99 Audubon Street, New Haven, 06510

  
• Sweet Anna's Organics Juice - Essex

  1 North Main Street, Essex, 06426

  
• Juicy Naam - East Hampton

  27 Race Lane, East Hampton, 11937

  
• Hampton Coffee Company - Southampton

  749 County Road 39A, Southampton, 11968

  
• juice press - Southampton

  93 Main Street, Southampton, 11968

  
• Giving Room - Southold

  56215 Main Road, Southold, 11971

  

 

Chocolate Shops

Chocolate Shops in Shelter Island

 

• Dylan's Candy Bar - East Hampton

  52 Main Street, East Hampton, 11937

  
• Given Fine Chocolates & Indulgences - Madison

  696 Boston Post Road, Madison, 06443

  
• Truffle Shots - Essex

  1 North Main Street, Essex, 06426

  
• Mali B Sweets - Greenport

  130 Front Street, Greenport, 11944

  
• Munson's Chocolates - Orange

  109 Boston Post Road, Orange, 06477

  
• Port Jefferson Frigate - Port Jefferson

  99 Main Street, Port Jefferson, 11777

  
• Double Rainbow Treats - Quogue

  140 Jessup Avenue, Quogue, 11959

  
• Fudge Company - Southampton

  67 Main Street, Southampton, 11968

  

 

Cookie Shops

Cookie Shops in Shelter Island

 

• Insomnia Cookies - New Haven

  1143 Chapel Street, New Haven, 06511

  
• Catie's Cookies - Hamden

  33 Baldwin Road, Hamden, 06514

  
• Entenmann's Bakery - Orange

  284 Bull Hill Lane, Orange, 06477

  
• Pepperidge Farm - Riverhead

  1770 West Main Street, Riverhead, 11901

  
• Sweet Andy's Cookies - Westhampton Beach, Westhampton Bch

  136 Riverhead Road, Westhampton Beach, Westhampton Bch, 11978

  
• Icing On the Cake Bakery - Stratford

  3641 Main Street, Stratford, 06614

  
• Mighty DelightySweets & Treats - Sayville

  24 Aldrich Street, Sayville, 11782

  
• Tate's Bake Shop Commissary - East Moriches

  62 Pine Street, East Moriches, 11940

  

 

Sandwich Shops

Sandwich Shops in Shelter Island

 

• Country Heroes - Westhampton Beach, Westhampton Bch

  77 Montauk Highway, Westhampton Beach, Westhampton Bch, 11978

  
• Panera Bread - Bridgehampton

  2044 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton, 11932

  
• Cove Delicatessen - Sag Harbor

  283 Main Street, Sag Harbor, 11963

  
• SUBWAY Restaurants - Water Mill

  760 Montauk Highway, Water Mill, 11976

  
• Deli Counter - Southampton

  623 Hampton Road, Southampton, 11968

  
• Sterlington Deli - Greenport

  3 Sterlington Commons, Greenport, 11944

  
• Subway - Mattituck

  10095 Main Road, Mattituck, 11952

  

 

Deli Shops

Deli Shops in Shelter Island

 

• Mike's Quality Meats & Fine - Old Saybrook

  1522 Boston Post Road, Old Saybrook, 06475

  
• Harbourfront Deli - Greenport

  48 Front Street, Greenport, 11944

  
• Grateful Lee Deli - Southold

  55700 Route 25, Southold, 11971

  
• SUBWAY Restaurants - Hampton Bays

  105 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, 11946

  
• Antique Catering & Deli - Mattituck

  10560 Main Road, Mattituck, 11952

  
• Taste of Poland - Cutchogue

  32854 Main Road, Cutchogue, 11935

  

 

Salad Shops

Salad Shops in Shelter Island

 

• marco polo pizzeria and italian restaurant - New Haven

  55 Crown Street, New Haven, 06510

  
• Paul's Pasta Shop - Groton

  223 Thames Street, Groton, 06340

  
• Hellenic Snack Bar and Restaurant - East Marion

  5145 Main Road, East Marion, 11939

  
• World Pie - Bridgehampton

  2402 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton, 11932

  
• Pacifico - New Haven

  220 College Street, New Haven, 06510

  
• Little Salad Shop - New Haven

  45 High Street, New Haven, 06510

  

 

Pie Shops

Pie Shops in Shelter Island

 

• Lenny Bruno Farms - Manorville

  740 Wading River Road, Manorville, 11949

  
• Krafty Kakes - Wallingford

  39 North Plains Industrial Road, Wallingford, 06492

  
• Lucky Girl Bakery LLC - Preston

  22 Old Shetucket Turnpike, Preston, 06365

  

 

Donut Shops

Donut Shops in Shelter Island

 

• Dunkin' Donuts (20 County Road 39) - Southampton

  20 County Road 39, Southampton, 11968

  
• Dunkin' Donuts - Southold

  53345 New York State Bicycle Route 25, Southold, 11971

  

 

Pastry Shops

Pastry Shops in Shelter Island

 

• Marjolaine Pastry Shop - New Haven

  961 State Street, New Haven, 06511

  

 

Other Takeouts

Other Takeouts in Shelter Island

 

• Papa John's Pizza - Mount Sinai

  152 Nesconset Highway, Mount Sinai, 11766

  
• Zorba The Greek II - Port Jefferson Station

  572 Jefferson Plaza, Port Jefferson Station, 11776

  
• China East Restaurant - Selden

  1070 Middle Country Road, Selden, 11784

  
• Tony's Fusion West - Westhampton Bch

  23 Sunset Avenue, Westhampton Bch, 11978-2323

  
• Country Cottage Diner - Center Moriches

  Center Moriches, 11934-3509

  
• Setauket Village Diner - Setauket East Setauket

  Setauket East Setauket, 11733-2853

  
• KFC (1314 Tanger Mall Drive) - Riverhead

  1314 Tanger Mall Drive, Riverhead, 11901-6413

  

 

Best reviews

Top takeout restaurants in Shelter Island

Takeout Restaurants yet to be reviewed

 

Top dessert shops in Shelter Island

Dessert Shops yet to be reviewed

 

Top butcher shops in Shelter Island

Butcher Shops yet to be reviewed

 

Top bagel shops in Shelter Island

Bagel Shops yet to be reviewed

 

Top cheese shops in Shelter Island

Cheese Shops yet to be reviewed

 

Top juice shops in Shelter Island

Juice Shops yet to be reviewed

 

Top chocolate shops in Shelter Island

Chocolate Shops yet to be reviewed

 

Top cookie shops in Shelter Island

Cookie Shops yet to be reviewed

 

Top sandwich shops in Shelter Island

Sandwich Shops yet to be reviewed

 

Top deli shops in Shelter Island

Deli Shops yet to be reviewed

 

Top salad shops in Shelter Island

Salad Shops yet to be reviewed

 

Top pie shops in Shelter Island

Pie Shops yet to be reviewed

 

Top donut shops in Shelter Island

Donut Shops yet to be reviewed

 

Top pastry shops in Shelter Island

Pastry Shops yet to be reviewed

 

Top other takeouts in Shelter Island

Other Takeouts yet to be reviewed